Initial results on election night put Keith Wilson in the lead, but another round of ballots is scheduled to be added to the tally on Wednesday afternoon.
Commissioners Dan Ryan, Mingus Mapps and Rene Gonzalez, who previously pushed the plan, now say they'll leave the decision up to the new council next year.
Incumbent Congresswoman Marie Gluesenkamp Perez, a Democrat, narrowly beat Republican Joe Kent in 2022. This year, Kent sought to reverse that outcome.